Etche Homo (behold the man)

Monday 31st December 2007 7 hours 30 min

Re-etched reverse side of HS parts and primed, 2nd coated HS parts. Primed HS skins (2 costs). Cleaned VS parts (except skins) & elevator stiffners. Cleaned rudder skins. 1st coat primed rudder skins.

Alright, it's Christmas not Easter and the proper spelling is "Ecce" but otherwise it seems apt to call attention to a miserable specimen who spends his holidays on such a pursuit as this.

The instructions for the Ekoetch say that you must prime within three hours. However, the primer is taking so long to dry that I could only paint one side of the HS parts yesterday and that means that the Ekoetch was well past that deadline. So I decided to apply further Ekoetch. I was afraid that it would soften the primer on the finished side but it seemed to have no effect so the primer seems to have cured well overnight.


I was trying to get a sequence going and move sets of parts through the cleaning, etching and priming phases in some sort of orderly fashion. However, it is difficult to keep everything in line. Anyway, my spraying technique was a bit better today. I haven't changed the settings on the gun at all, they seem to be okay, though I have nothing to compare them against.

Want to see my Etching?

Sunday 30th December 2007 8 Hours
Etched elevator parts. Cleaned rudder parts except skin. Dimpled R902 spar and R918 attach strips. Drilled deburred and dimpled counterbalance weight and rib. Primed HS parts 1 side.
Quite a few bits got left behind in the first phase of parts preparation. In some cases, like the R-918 attach strips, it was just that I forgot a step. In others, like the rudder counterbalance weight and ribs, it was because I did not have the #10 drill required. However, I ordered that from Averys along with a few other bits and pieces and they had arrived a few days before the Christmas shut-down.






I finally got to try some spraying. First I set up the gun using a method I found on the internet. When I had a reasonable flat vertical spray pattern with a rate of flow that was neither too fast or too slow, I began to prepare the primer itself. First I had to dilute it to get the viscosity down to the 20 second mark recommended by Stewarts. Viscosity is measured by timing the stream of paint coming from a hole in the bottom of a special cup that is dipped in the paint and then withdrawn. You start timing when you raise the cup and you stop the clock when the constant stream breaks into drops. The thicker the liquid, the longer this takes. Getting to 20 sec seemed to take an awful lot of water. Incidentally, I could not find distilled water for sale anywhere (chemists [drugstores]paint shops both came up blank) I eventually found de-ionised battery top-up water in a motor accessories store and they assured me it was in fact distilled water. I had to stop at 25 second viscosity because I was approaching the maximum dilution of 33% allowed by the product instructions. Anyway, I thought is was no hard to have the paint a little bit too thick - better than having it too thin.

The spraying went well, I thought, but the paint took a lot longer to dry than I expected. The first lot looked as if it was not going to dry at all. However, after over an hour, it had finally dried. It is supposed to dry within about 20 minutes. I worried that the de-ionised water was chemically active in some way and was preventing the paint from drying.




Washing up

29th December 2hrs 45min

Cleaned HS parts

This was my first experience of the Stewarts EkoEtch product. It seems very innocuous and I hesitated to dilute it 1:20 in water as instructed. However it is actually very powerful and it takes off Sharpie markings quite effectively. As a result I had to devise a way of identifying the parts so that they will be assembled in the right places for which they were match drilled. However, some parts are duplicated between left and right HS, so I did all the parts for these assemblies in batches and kept them separate.


I bought a large plastic under-bed storage chest for the cleaning/degreasing operation, on the basis that it would allow me to imerse the maximum size and number of parts in the least amount of fluid. I am not sure if this was really of much benefit. I stored the diluted cleaning fluid in it afterwards as it seemed to have lots of potency left. However, I might have been just as well just making up small amounts in a bowl and dipping my cleaning pad in it as required. I could then have cleaned the parts on my bench, suitably covered with some plastic covering.

I used the red Scotchbrite pads for this operation and they certainly scuff up the surface nicely. In fact, when the parts were rinsed afterwards, the water sheets off like it is supposed to do after the next etching step. Effectively, the parts have been mechanically etched. This is undoubtedly overkill but I think I will continue with it nonetheless as it is very satisfying to see how well the parts come up once all the tiny scratches dissapear in this scuffing operation.

Spray set up

27th December 5 hr

Setting up for priming
I got a few hours away from the Christmas festivities today to get ready for the priming operation.

The access to the booth proved a problem because the velcro is so agressive and because,when you pull the sides apart, you are shortening the height of the walls so the floor has to come up. This made getting in and out, particularly in full painting regalia while holding parts, very awkward. Because of this, I taped up the old corner entrance and cut a full-sized roll-up door in one of the side walls. The 'door' was cut from spare Powerclad material as it had to overlap the opening. I re-used the velcor (expensive stuff) tape to fix it to the opening at three points down each side and one across the bottom. This works quite well. When I take the booth down I might consider using a long zip to close the 'door'; just as you would find in a tent. I could then open or close it single handed in one movement.

I found some useful advice on setting up a spray gun in the Stewarts procedures manual and supplemented this with some more information that I found on-line. There was quite a bit of trial and error involved so I taped some newspaper to the inside of the booth and filled the gun with water. Using something with a colour in it would make this trial and error process a lot easier but would create more mess. I didn't want to waste any primer so I just made do. In the end, I got what I thought was a nice narrow vertical oval shaped spray pattern and the liquid seemed to be coming out of the nozzel at a reasonably good rate.

Spray booth

Wed 19th January 2hr 45min and Sat 22nd Hanuary 6hr 30 min

Constructed Spraybooth

Finally, I have all the parts ready for priming. In an earlier blog, I have already expressed my views on the priming issue and how I came to decide on using the Stewarts Systems product range to prime the entire interior of the plane. Subsequently, I bought a new HVLP gravity fed spray gun on eBay that I am looking forward to using. Now I need to set up a spray booth that will be easily demountable and will store in a compact format.

I am trying to use as little stiffening structure as possible as I want to be able to roll this thing up and store it above the rafters of the shop. However, normal polythene sheet ("Visqueen") did not seem to be robust enough. Passing a building site one day, I noticed the material they use for cladding scaffolding. This stuff is a polythene sheet with a 'net' of polythene cord molded into it. It is supplied in horizontal strips 2 meters high and these are joined together top and bottom to form a tarpaulin of the exact height needed for the scaffold. Subsequently, I found that this material is called "Powerclad" and it is available in rolls from scaffolding hire and sales companies. A roll of 60 meters costs €120 plus VAT but luckily, the guys at the place I went to sold me an end of a roll with more than enough left for my needs and charged me very little money.

Some builders have constructed small spray booths with open fronts that just catch overspray. I want something bigger that I can actually get into and paint a reasonable number of parts at a time, including large parts such as empennage skins. I decided on six feet square mainly because that was the length of the pieces of stiffening timber that I bought.

I began by cutting a 24 foot length of powerclad to go around all four sides and form the walls and two six ft. squares for the roof and floor. These were made up into a cube by taping the seams with duct tape. All of this material almost took over the shop! The entrance was originally at the corner where the ends of the 'wall' material came together. I used a length of velcro take to make this join and thought I would easily be able to get in an out through this. It certainly was effective because, with the velcor closed, the thing would stand on its own by virtue of the air trapped inside and would only deflate over a period of 5-10 minutes. However, it was really difficult to open the velcro and climb through. So later, I cut a full sized door attached with tape at the top and fastened with intermittent short lengths of velcro down each side and across the bottom. To make sure it hangs properly, I taped a lenght of timber to the bottom as a weight.

I put in two lengths of 2X1 timber along opposite sides of the wall-roof join and stappled these to the Powerclad. In use, the booth is suspended from these stiffeners which are hung from the shop ceiling by hooks and ropes fixed into the timber and corresponding hooks in the walls and joists of the shop structure. In order to hold the walls reasonably taut, I covered the floor with some 1/8 in. hardboard that I had in stock.




Because the thing was so airtight, I decided that I needed to provide for ventilation. A shower fan and cheap plactic ducting leading out through the window provided for the extraction but I also needed a way for the air to get in, otherwise the extractor would to try to deflate the booth and suck the walls in. Again, it was important not to have anything still that would create difficulties when rolling up the booth for storage. The answer was a replacement filter for a cooker extraction hood, which comes in a sheet about 30 in. by 24 in. I cut out a corresponding rectangle from the Powerclad and taped this filter material in place with duct tape supplemented by office staples. This should filter out any dust as the air comes in.

Penance for old sins


Sun 16th Dec 9hrs 30min



Countersunk HS-902-L spar and prepped edges. Cut replacement R-915 A&B stiffeners and match-drilled to rudder skin. Prepped R-915s. Made replacement HS-908 attach angles.


I did the countersinking of the HS-902 spar flanges to accept the skin dimples. This was the part where I had ruined the original part so I took it easy, making sure that the head of a size 3 countersunk rivet fitted down completely in the countersink so that it does not stop a fingernail drawn across the rivet. On this occassion I was careful to get it just right but I am not entirely certain that the skin dimples are fitting down enough, even if the rivet heads are okay. However, Vans support said clearly that the countersinks need to be set deep enough for the relevant rivets, not the dimple that sits into it.


The rudder is one of those areas where it is hard to arrange to drill through the parts that have already been match-drilled into the new parts. The skin is very floppy, even with the stiffeners clecoed to it. So, sespit what I said last Thursday, I drilled through the new part into the old. I seem to have got away with it as all the holes seem fine.

I was not happy with the second set of HS-908 attach angles. They were infinitely better than the first set but still a little smaller than the designed dimenions so, as I was having other parts sent, I decided to sport the $5 for the short length of angle required. This time, I marked very carefully and stayed well away from the lines with the bank saw. I then used a hand file and digital calipers to come right down to the exact dimensions required. Finally, I rounded off the corners to match the full-size drawings. They took a surprisingly long time as the 9 HS902/7 attach holes have to be drilled and then the angles have to be match-drilled to the HS-907 doubler and HS-902 spars. In the case of the left attach-angles, I only drilled the location hole and then did the remaining drilling throught the already match-drilled holes in the spar and doubler. Naturally, I clamped a straight edge across the two angles to ensure their bottom webs are in the same plane.

Eventually, I was happy that my HS-908s are spot on and all the other little 'oops' to date had been cleared up. Pity abut that trim tab.

Skinned again

Thurs 14th Dec 2hr 15 min

RE-assembled R-HS skeleton and skin and match-drilled HS902-R

In order to complete the match-drilling of the replacement HS-902, it was necessary to assemble the full skeleton and match drill through each rib into the web of the spar. Then the skeleton had to be assembled in the skin so that the flanges of the spar could be match-drilled to the skin.

This was a simple process and went without significant problems. Of course the skin does not fit as well as on the old spar because it has been dimpled and the spar flanges have not yet been countersunk. Consequently, the skin sits on its dimples and does not yet lie flat against the spar. This knocks out the alignment of the remaining holes in the skin and main ribs so I decided that I would not cleco these for the match-drilling operation.

Finishing the Trim Tab Preparation

Tue 10th Dec 2hr 30 min

Prepared the trim tab skin and spar edges. Deburred spar and skin. Countersunk the spar top flange and dimpled the bottom flange holes. Prepared and dimpled the horn pieces. Assembled HS-902 r & L with the HS-907 doubler and match-drilled them.











While I am thinking about getting a replacement trim tab skin, I went ahead and prepped this one, in case I decide to use it. This is not the easiest of jobs. It would have been better to prep the edges at the end of the skin before bending the tabs for instance. I tackled the leading edges initially with the spar clecoed in. This was okay for the lower edge but the spar was interfering with getting a good surface on the upper edge so I disassembled it and worked 'free-hand' with the small Scotchbrite wheel in the die grinder.

There is no more I can do on the trim tab for the moment so I began work on the recently arrived replacement parts. I started with the HS-902 L and R and the HS-907 front spar doubler. The trick here (and in any situation where you are preparing replacement parts) is to use the holes in the parts that have not been replaced as the 'master' holes for match-drilling the new part. If you drill from the new part into the old, you can get mismatched elongated holes. In this case, there was no problem on the right as both the spar and doubler were new but I was careful to drill from the aft side through the spar into the doubler on the left. This is the opposite direction to the original match-drilling.

Trim tab - Another right mess

Sun 9th Dec 3hrs 10Min

Made bending break. Masked and sanded the site of the trim tab foam ribs. Trimmed the trim tab horns and match-drilled. Completed the Trim Tab trailing edge skin bend. Made blocks and bent end tabs. Match-drilled ends and skin to spar holes.

The replacement HS-902 and HS-907 arrived during the week along with the angle needed to make replacement R-915 A&B stiffeners and the angle to make a third(!) set of HS-908 attach angles. I am looking forward to preparing these pieces and eliminating all my past sins. However, I scarcely have the replacement pieces in my hands when I mess up another piece. This time it is the trim tab skin, but more of that later.

I made the bending break from two of my shelves as they were the only pieces of timber I had of about the right side. They in turn had been made from scraps of half-inch ply that I had left over from building the workshop and I had glued two thicknesses together to get the stiffness I needed for the shelves. The bend was not as smooth as I expected and it seemed to vary depending on where I had leaned on the break. However, I got it straight with a bit of trial and error. When I inserted the spar, I found that it was a little over-bent so I put it over the edge of another piece of half-inch ply and pushed gently down on the trailing edge. This spread the bend out a little until the spar fitted perfectly in position at the 'open' leading edge.










The manual shows pictures of the set-up for bending the tabs on the skin to form the ends of the trim tab. This is done using interlocking blocks, one of which is cut to go inside the skin and the other goes on top. The whole assembly is positioned on the edge of a bench and clamped tightly. Another picture shows the tab being bent with a mushroom set in a rivet gun. I also watched the Orndorff DVD again but George just refers to having bent the tabs using his flanging tool. I decided to go with the Vans procedure so I made the interlocking blocks from three-quarter inch MDF that I had lying around, clamped it all up and went at it initially with a timber block and a hammer and then finished off with the rivet gun.

To say the least of it, the results are not good. There were two problems. Firstly, despite heavy clamping, the blocks moved slightly, so the first bend did not end up on the line where it was supposed to be. Secondly, the rivet gun hammered the hell out of the skin leaving it over-bent and all dinged up. Maybe the part is okay from a functional point of view and the problems are only really visible at the edges but I don't think I can live with it.










Afterwards, I searched the forums for other people's ideas. The Orndorff video simply refers to using the flanging tool to make the bends but does not show it. I found that lots of builders have problems with this task, so much so that the replacement skin is with the accessories in the main on-line store rather in "the list" with virtually all of the other kit parts. Those who have done the job successfully are using timber blocks that are much thicker than mine - up to 2 inches. Some have also suggested using double-sided scotch tape between the skin and the blocks to prevent movement. Too bloody late now of course.

Left Elevator completed and on to Trim Tab

Sat 8th Dec 7hr 10min

Dimpled the left elevator skin and stripped vinyl from the inside and from the rivet lines on the outside. Prepped and dimpled the E-902 and E-907. Countersunk the E-907 top flange. Made the E-921 gusset. Made trim tab clamps. Made trim tab ribs and marked their position.

The springiness of the elevator skins makes dimpling awkward. If it was not for the DRDT2, I could not have managed it alone but this dimpler leaves you with one hand for the work and it does the job without too much fuss.

Dimpling the spars was the first outing for my new small diameter dimple dies. Perhaps I could have made do without them but it's great not to have to worry about the die digging into the curve of the metal. I don't have a particular problem with the idea of grinding one side off the full-size dies but as we are only talking about $17 per die, I think it is better to have the correct tool for the job. Postage was effectively free as I had to get a replacement for the #40 countersink cutter anyway.

I have remarked before how tedious it is to set up a countersink cage for a particular rivet size. There is no calibration so it is a trial and error process that takes a lot of time and care to get it right. Even now, having done it three or four times, it still takes 15 minutes or more each time. Some builders recommend getting three countersink cages and leaving one permanently set up for #40, a second for #30. The third is then used for any other sizes that crops up. This would save a lot of time. I think it is worthwhile so I will order two more cages the next time I need something from Avery or Isham.

Making the E-921 gusset was not a problem. I don't have a deadblow hammer so I used a normal hammer with a piece of wood scrap against the metal. I did the bending in my vice, to which I have fitted wooden jaws. While I was fitting out the shop before the kit arrived, I had looked for soft jaws from a number of local tool shops but couldn't find them so eventually I made some from teak scraps and fitted them in place of the metal ones. The teak is hard enough to get a firm grip but I have never noticed any marks on metal pieces that come out of the vice.

I decided to postpone the drilling of the trailing edge for the moment. I may wait until the remainder of the elevator is riveted. If I do that I will have to prime the wedge extrusion on its own as all the other pieces will already have been primed but I feel I will get a better result if the structure is already stiffened up before I set the trailing edge.

The band saw was very useful for cutting out the V clamps for the trim tab as well as the foam ribs. I don't bother changing back to a timber saw blade for these small jobs. The metal blade does a good job if you give it plenty of time. The belt sander made quick work of tidying up the foam ribs but I had to use sandpaper for the clamps. I finished up the day by marking the location where the ribs will go inside the skin of the trim tab.

Left Elevator Edge Preparation

Tue 4th Dec 1hr 40min

Preped the edges of the Left elevator skin and skeleton parts and trim servo doubler and cover plate

The elevator skins are difficult to handle. My two bench-edge vices with the lengths of timber running between them were a help for the trailing edges. However the elevators are longer than the horizontal stabilisers, vertical stabilisers and rudder and I only had two lengths of timber long enough. Still, I managed by using a shorter piece between the two trailing edges and a clamp in the middle to counteract the bowing of the outer timbers.

The edges around the hinge openings in the leading edge also needed to be prepped. In this case, I held the skin between two lengths of timber lying loosly in my vice. The vices were set to about two thirds of the width of the leading edge so that the skin just rested there in a good position for access. No clamping force was used so it was not held securely and one hand had to be on the work all the time, but it went okay.

When it came to the ends, unlike the VS for example, the elevator was much longer than the height of my table so I had to secure the piece to the table top as best I could and work horizontally over the table's edge. The outboard end was okay as I could get a piece of timber clamped across the section of skin that overlaps the counterbalance assembly and still leave the edge of the skin just overlapping the edge of the table. For the angled outboard end, all I could do was put one clamp on the trailing edge and another on the edge I was working on, moving it as necessary. This provided some support but was not ideal.

I used wet and dry paper on most of these edges (other than the trailing edges) as I felt they were too delicate for the small scotchbrite wheel in the die grinder, especially as the work was not securely held in most cases.

Match-drilling Elevator Stiffeners

Mon 3rd Dec 2hr 30min

Match-drilled stiffeners to left Elevator skin

With the experience of the right elevator, this was no problem. There are two wrinkles: Firstly, all but one of the stiffeners are left-handed (the flange with the holes is to the left of the vertical web when looking forward). This means that when you install them in the top skin, the reverse is true and the flange extends across the skin to the right of the the vertical web. The end effect is that the webs of the top and bottom stiffeners do not interfere with each other because they are separated by the width of the flanges. Secondly, the only exception to this rule is E-908 - R which closes off the edge of the elevator in the recess where it abutts the trim tab. In this case the two webs will lie cheek by cheek with two pop-rivets through the two of them.

The second issue is simpler still. It is that the 5 long E908-L stiffeners go in the full width section of the elevator and the shorter E-909 stiffeners go in the narrower section forward of the trim tab.

The E-616PP trim cover plate is itself a stiffener and is match-drilled in place at this stage also.

On to the Left Elevator

Sunday 2nd Dec 7hrs 40min

Prepared the edges of all remaining right elevator parts. Dimpled the skin. Assembled Left Elevator skeleton and skin and match-drilled all parts. Cut and prepped the edges of skin stiffeners.

The manual contains plenty of fair warnings about the left elevator. They say that it is responsible for a very large proportion of support calls for the RV-9 kit. Suitably chastened by all this, I got the parts together and began.

I initially cut all the stiffeners to the standard length and did the filing at blunt (forward) end. This was to establish a fixed point from which to measure the length at which the short ones should be cut. Once the first of these short stiffeners was measured off, I decided to cut the whole lot in one go on the band saw (which has been having a quiet time of late). I probably should have taken care to line up the forward holes of all the stiffeners in my stack but I did not think of it and just used the forward end to allign them together. Anyway, the band saw went through them as if through butter and there was none of the 'chatter' and fuss I found when sawing such thin material one piece at a time. Naturally, I stayed well back from the cut line to leave plenty of safety margin and I tidied them up using my belt sander to remove material back to the exact length required. They turned out just fine and not aligning the forward holes does not seem to have caused any problem.


Match drilling them to the skin was essentially a repeat of the process for the right elevator except that securing the trailing edge of the skin took a little extra ingenuity. The problem is that the 'indent' where the trim tab goes means that most of the trailing edge is not near the edge of the bench where it can be secured (or else the rest of the trailing edge is overhanging the bench and you have nothing to drill into). I came up with the solution pictured here, using scrap timber placed on the bench so that it slightly overlaps the trailing edge and screwing this timber to the bench just beyond this overlap with the edge of the skin.



The instructions refer to dimpling the E615PP for #6 screws. I don't really understand this as I thought the nut plates would rule that out. I will have to look into this further but for now I just match drilled the holes for riveting the E-615PP to the skin. Incidentally, it is the vinyl that is wrinkled in this photo, not the skin itself.